Results 1 to 4 of 4

Thread: Horrific PIP Assessment...

  1. #1

    Horrific PIP Assessment...

    Hi guys

    Yes, it was time for my 3rd PIP assessment.

    I was up at 3.30am as I have an awful sleep pattern due to fibromyalgia. I take tramadol (which is useless as a painkiller unfortunately). I also have stress/anxiety with IBS which was going berserk in knowing what I would have to do this day.

    The way I try to prepare for these is to have (a) my medical diagnosis from specialists of all my conditions, (b) how my conditions affect me and (c) applicable Upper Tribunal Case Law regarding how these satisfy a particular descriptor. I had prepared for 18 months for this to the best of my ability getting loads of medical evidence and a thorough "how my condition affects me" submission. The assessment, however, was horrific.

    I was already extremely fatigued due to lack of sleep and in extreme pain due to my fibromyalgia as well as going to the loo numerous times due to the stress and anxiety triggering bouts of IBS. The assessor was barking questions with a 'why' to absolutely everything I said. "Why do you wear incontinence pads"; does she need me to draw a diagram??!! I was getting more and more embarrassed, stressed and I just wanted out of there - by the end I was saying pretty much anything and everything to get out the door before I lost the plot.....

    I have a few questions:

    How much relevance is put on evidence from medical professionals? How old does evidence have to be before it's no longer relevant? For example, I have letters from an Occupational Therapist (showing how my fibromyalgia is affecting me and the need to move to more suitable accommodation 2018), a physiotherapist (showing how my fibromyalgia affects me and a care plan I need to put into action but struggling to do so due to the stress and anxiety of the PIP process 2018), a rheumatologist (fibromyalgia diagnosis and how it affects me 2014), colorectal surgeon (faecal incontinence also showing panic attacks as I needed a camera test but needed to have a general anaesthetic to get it done 2018), GP (list of diagnosis 2017) and a CBT therapist (whose evidence the tribunal for my current PIP award was of found importance - 2014/2015). I also included a receipt for a bath step and a letter from my council I have a condition which means I need to move (although a 2 year wait is likely).

    I also gave a 9 page thorough description of each descriptor I satisfied (1b or 1e) - current award 1b, 3b, 4b - current award 4b, 5b, 9d - current award 9d, Mobility 1d and 2f. Within this submission I included excerpts from the Assessment Guide Part 2 such as being reliant on pre-prepared vegetables or using my alarm on my mobile for medication purposes. I have also used Upper Tribunal Cases such as CPIP/3104/2017 for needing incontinence pads overnight and CPIP/1127/2017 as well as CPIP/2983/2016 for Descriptor 9.

    I did not get a mobility component last time but the laws have now changed and I know that pain, fatigue, breathlessness, mental health etc are now taken into account (or at least meant to be). I stated CPIP/1347/2015 and CPIP/1328/2016 relevant to Mobility 1d. I tried to stress I would have panic attacks (shown in numerous evidences that I have these) in trying to follow a route I didn't know and I always have a taxi to travel anywhere I don't know. I was asked if I can travel on public transport which I do TO PLACES I KNOW like to my family. I was asked if I could read a map from A to B - I said I wouldn't do this and I would need a taxi no matter what especially with panic attacks and symptoms of fibromyalgia.
    For 2f I stated 'CPIP/665/2016, CPIP/2377/2015 and PIP Assessment Guide (2016), 3.2.5 'Impact' - including Pain, discomfort, breathlessness, fatigue and anxiety' all relevant. I can walk with a walking stick but any distance walked causes significant pain and I push through this pain to be independent and not stuck in 4 walls all of the time!

    The assessor was quite rude, abrupt and told me off when using the word 'descriptors'. I felt as though I was in a Gestapo interrogation. She noted 'you got a lot of points last time' which makes me think she's going to take them all away this time and she said 'I think it's funny that you have awarded yourself points' in regards to the submission showing each descriptor I felt I should be awarded etc. She wanted to do all the physical assessments which I declined to do any of them as I was in too much pain but then wanted me to fill in a form but made me try to reach across a desk to get it. I saw through that straight away.....

    What does anyone think of this? I feel my intelligence is going against me massively. I have business qualifications and I have (classroom) legal experience but both of these do not make my conditions better. I say Sir Stephen Hawking was one of the most intelligent men on Earth but this did not mean he could leap out of his wheelchair and recover from his conditions!!!

    I know I have to wait for her report (or more than likely bunch of lies as so many PIP farce to farce appointments are). If the report has as much fact as Lord of the Rings, how much weight would that report have against my plethora of evidence I have from numerous medical sources listed above?

    Any thought?

    Slash 1975

  2. #2
    Senior Member gus607's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2016
    Wait until you see a copy of the report first, you never know !

  3. #3
    Just received notification DWP have the report & decision in approx 6 weeks will be made...

    Not sure if there's anything to read into them getting it so fast but I've obviously requested a copy which I'll get next week somewhen...

  4. #4
    I have the written report!

    To say that it is bad is an understatement. Hilariously bad in fact. It took 35 mins for her to write the report with literally hundreds of spelling mistakes (OK we're not the spelling police but professionalism thrown out the window imho) and hugely obvious inconsistencies throughout. A glaringly ridiculous and obvious one is the 'Social and Occupational History' showing "he does not drive" and for the 'planning and following journeys descriptor' she has put "he is able to drive and uses satnav and maps" etc....

    The fact that (a) I do not own a car and (b) I HAVE HAD MY DRIVING LICENCE SUSPENDED DUE TO MY MEDICAL ISSUES - which the assessor knew all about and evidences from the DVLA were provided, and (c) as a result of not being allowed to drive I am in receipt of a Disabled Persons Bus Pass.

    Bit of a "d'oh" moment there me thinks.....

    I have been awarded 8 points in the report overall, most were expected although she gave 0 points for 'engaging with others face to face' when 4 years ago I was awarded the full 8 at tribunal. In the assessment she referred to this as 'meeting new people' which is NOT the descriptor - it is a mere part of it. Throughout the report 'attending alone' seems to override many of my conditions; in my case, I am alone. I have no friends. I have no support. Why should that count against me? I have mental health reports which the tribunal I attended in Nov 2014 held important to my claim which gave the 8 points. I finished the CBT but there's no point in therapy's sake - my situation is permanent...

    Oh well, looks like I'm going to have to pick this report to pieces because like to many, many others, it's not worth the paper it's printed on....

Similar Threads

  1. Esa assessment terminated......on assessment rate now for nearly a!!!
    By ultan in forum Benefits - help & advice on disability benefits, incapacity benefits, ESA and DLA
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 09-03-17, 17:58
  2. Replies: 1
    Last Post: 12-04-13, 00:03

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts